What’s the Deal?

AFC Wimbledon have agreed a deal in principle to sign midfielder James Tilly from Wycombe, the club announced. The 28-year-old New Zealand native, who spent the second half of last season on loan at Plough Lane, is set to finalize his transfer after completing a medical expected within 24 hours, per Sky Sports.

Tilly contributed two goals and two assists in 13 appearances during his loan stint. His move to AFC Wimbledon will reunite him with manager Johnnie Jackson, who oversaw the player’s previous spell at the club.

Why James Tilly Matters for AFC Wimbledon

The Dons, currently 24th in League One with 0 points, are rebuilding ahead of the 2026-27 campaign. Tilly’s experience in League One — including his recent performances against sides like Accrington Stanley and Oxford United — could add depth to a midfield that struggled for creativity last season.

Tilly joined Wycombe in 2025 on a free transfer but found first-team opportunities limited. A permanent switch to AFC Wimbledon offers both parties a fresh start, with the player aiming to replicate his loan form at Plough Lane.

What Comes Next?

While the deal is all but finalized, Tilly must pass his medical to complete the transfer. AFC Wimbledon fans will hope the midfielder can help stabilize a team that conceded 82 goals in 46 league games last season.

The club’s next fixture is a home match against Bromley on February 13, 2027. With both teams at the wrong end of the table (Bromley sit 23rd), the game could be a crucial early test for Tilly and his new teammates.